Wichita district launches new “opportunity” school for disruptive students

The Wichita, Kansas school district is launching a new “Opportunity Academy” for misbehaving students that will focus more extensively on developing character – an effort to address increasing disciplinary problems in recent years.

The number of suspensions, detentions and trips to the principal’s office in Wichita elementary schools increased from 8,762 four years ago to13,500 incidents last year, despite the fact that district enrollment decreased.

District wide, discipline issues are up 11 percent, and teachers union officials have complained about chaos in the classroom, according to The Wichita Eagle.

“We’ve been looking at areas of need, both academically and in terms of behavior,” district spokesman Terrell Davis said. “And one of those areas is kids who just need additional structure and a hands-on approach.”  School board members unanimously approved a new Bryant Opportunity Academy at a recent meeting to help students “who need a more highly structured, controlled environment,” Davis said.

The Academy will serve 100 kindergarten through sixth grade students who have struggled at other schools by offering smaller class sizes, additional counselors and social workers, and a strong focus on character development, according to the news site.

The effort is part of a broader push to address disciplinary problems that started with daily lessons on character and social and emotional skills at all elementary schools last year.

“We’re looking at school differently for a group of kids who … may not have learned how to play school,” Davis said. “This is a way to think outside of the box to serve those kids.”

The school will open in what was previously Bryant Elementary, one of five schools closed by the district in 2012. A new school funding formula directs additional money to “at-risk” students, though Davis said officials are describing troubled students in terms of “opportunity.”

“We don’t like to use the term ‘at-risk’ to describe our students. We use the term ‘opportunity,’” he said. “We really believe every child has the opportunity for greatness and success … They may come from different places and have different needs, and we just need to meet them wherever they are.”

Researchers at the Institute for Advanced Studies in Culture at the University of Virginia are cautious about instances where claims that shifts in vocabulary will reframe the experiences students will have once the new vocabulary are in effect.  Also, in instances where school authorities segregate disruptive students, it places an emphasis on fixing the individual student rather than addressing the deficits in the wider school culture of the previous school. Character is foremost a communal problem not simply an individual one. Moreover, Institute for Advanced Studies in Culture sociologist James Hunter in his book, The Death of Character, warns, “Neologisms from the moral education establishment, like ‘prosocial’ are only the most overt and self-conscious attempts to avoid the awkwardness of words like ‘good’ and ‘evil.’” “Troubled students” may well see through the shift in terminology from “at-risk” to “opportunity.” While well intentioned, sometimes it may be necessary start by naming the problem in stark moral terms.

Teachers and principals interested in strengthening the moral ecology of their school will find information and strategies at the UK’s The Jubilee Centre.

 

Cincinnati arts and technology program helps students refocus their lives

Students attending the Cincinnati Arts and Technology Studios are getting a second chance at graduating high school, along with lessons about character many are carrying with them to college.

Aislynn Bell told the Cincinnati Business Courier she came to CATS for education and training services, but later discovered the program offered much more than practical skills.

“I needed guidance and I needed some discipline and I needed a path to follow,” she said. “It gave me a goal. It gave me something to shoot for.”

CATS isn’t technically a high school, but rather a “credit recovery program” for teens at risk of not graduating on time.

“We’re using the visual arts to reconnect disenfranchised students,” said CATS CEO Clara Martin, a former Cincinnati Public Schools teacher. “The public high school can definitely provide the core curriculum, but if they need that elective credit in fine arts, they can come here to get that at off times.”

According to the Business Courier:

ATS’ mission is to give urban teens from across the region a chance to become productive citizens by providing arts education as motivation to stay in school, graduate and advance to higher learning. It offers five studio courses in tandem with character building, and through its Bridging the Gap program, it offers education and training services to graduates. These services provide a chance to change their lives when unemployment is a reality. 

Bell, a 2014 graduate who followed CATS’ digital multimedia track, also used the Bridging the Gap program to become a patient care assistant at Cincinnati Children’s Hospital. She said CATS offered a different experience that allowed students to own their work, while helping them to improve it.

“My favorite thing about it is they don’t tell you how to edit your picture; they teach you how to edit how you want to do it,” she said.

Researchers at the Institute for Advanced Studies in Culture commend programs of this type that use visual and fine arts. By their very nature these disciplines engage the more holistic right-brain phenomena. Rather than demanding or encouraging right and wrong answers, this participation in the arts takes the student’s own voice seriously. This is something that is often in short supply in the worlds in which they have been raised. This sense of ownership and voice strengthens their sense of agency. With agency comes hope that they can overcome their circumstances.

And while strengthening agency, they are also infusing the art with content specific virtues. These exercises are more than “pedagogies of permission,” that simply foster the unconstrained individual will. For more on the danger of “pedagogies of permission,” see The Tragedy of Moral Education in America.

CATS infuses art and technology lessons with a focus on character virtues like citizenship, perseverance, accountability, and the importance of higher education, while an ancillary Bridging the Gap component offers students training on everything from interviewing skills and email etiquette to certification training for nursing, manufacturing, construction, financial and other professions.

As the CATS program celebrates 15 years in downtown Cincinnati, many graduates returned to speak with current students about how the program changed their perspective on life.

“I feel like having the time and the ability to share my experience with these kids will give them a different outlook and a different way to see the program as a whole,” Ellen Pierce, a 23-year-old who went through the Bridging the Gap program, told students. “This could really lead to life-changing events.”

Pierce said she turned to CATS when she needed credit to graduate from Clark Montessori High School in 2012. Her success in the program gave her the confidence to become a State Tested Nursing Assistant through Bridging the Gap, and to earn a double-major at the University of Cincinnati. She now works two jobs, one at the Lindner Center of HOPE and another at the Cincinnati Children’s Hospital.

“If I didn’t get the credit, I wouldn’t have graduated on time,” she said. “That most definitely would have killed my self-esteem and my drive to keep going with life. If I wasn’t going to take the (State Tested Nursing Assistant) class to be certified, I probably wouldn’t have worked at Children’s.”

Educators and education leaders who are interested in the type of strategies used in the CATS program in Cleveland can learn more by going to

Social-emotional learning and achievement at Valor

Valor Collegiate Academies in Tennessee is crediting a sharp focus on social and emotional learning (SEL) for students’ astonishing academic success, which propelled its Tennessee schools to the top 1 percent of all middle schools in the state in its first year.

The success at Valor not only sheds light on the value of social-emotional learning, but also provides an opportunity to connect those lessons with broader discussions about good character and morals.

The Charter School Growth Fund, which invested $1.5 million for Valor’s first two schools launched in 2013, featured the schools in a recent “CSGF Portfolio Spotlight” on the organization’s website.

Todd Dickson, CEO of Valor Collegiate Academies, explained that the concept for the charter school was inspired by his work at a high-performing charter school in California that focused heavily on academics, and his twin brother Daren’s time helping children in social services with social and emotional skills.

“Students at Valor spend more time on their social and emotional growth than most traditional students. We first work on self-awareness and self-management to help them develop a strong sense of who they are. Then, we work on social awareness and social management to help them develop positive relationships with others. We believe that doing both things well helps develop healthy kids and communities,” Dickson said.

“We also hear from students that they feel safe here and that they have trusting relationships with peers and adults in the building. This has been beneficial in an academic setting; scholars are more willing to take academic risks. They listen to other people’s opinions and accept a diversity of perspectives.”

Valor schools use “The Valor Compass” to guide student growth and help them focus on four primary objectives: Sharp Minds, Noble Purpose, Big Hearts, and Aligned Actions.

“Mentor time, Expeditions, and academic courses all incorporate explicit and experiential experiences to help scholars develop sharp minds, big hearts, noble purpose, and aligned actions,” according to the Valor website. “Valor scholars develop character strengths such as kindness, determination, curiosity, gratitude, and integrity within a supportive community.”

Ryan Olson, director of the Institute for Advanced Studies on Culture at the University of Virginia, points out in “Character Education” that an SEL researcher argued that “the orientation of social-emotional learning toward action and skill” in SEL programs can complement the “concern for volition and intention often found in character and moral education programs.”

Adding curriculum resources on why students should do and be good—reasons outside oneself and for the benefit of others and a community—improves the stickiness of character formation, and getting students to go deeper by working on developing good sense when there is conflict between the social and emotional skills they’re learning, is an excellent next step, Olson argues.

The UK’s Jubilee Centre offers a worksheet to assist teachers to help students think about the kind of person and type of life they want to pursue.

School outreach to students, parents paying off

Administrators at Wyoming’s Albany County School District #1 are building trust with students and parents by engaging them in important decisions about curriculum development and graduation requirements, among other issues.

ACSD #1 Superintendent Jubal Yennie explained how the district is using student voices and feedback from the community to inform the district’s strategic decision-making in a recent webinar for K12 Insight.

The education website’s blog, TrustED, outlined how the process is paying off, for both school leaders looking to improve academics as well as student and families in the district.

“One of the things we’ll be working on this year is the whole graduation requirement,” Yennie said. “We’re finding that students have a great deal to say in this conversation. One of the things that’s resonated really well at the high school is this whole notion of purpose, where they’re actually saying the choices they’re provided in their programs is driving their desire to learn.”

Yennie explained that one of his top priorities as superintendent is to build trust among students, parents, and staff, and a comprehensive school quality survey for all three groups is providing valuable feedback on things like academic support, school leadership, and safety and behavior.

“We picked up very early on that our community and our students and staff all felt that we were doing a good job,” Yennie said. “We certainly celebrated that. I think the metric we picked up out of that was nine out of 10 people said we were doing excellent or good.”

The survey also showed where local schools could do better, he said, including better connections between what students are learning in class and how they can apply it in the real world.

“I think there’s some opportunity here with the curriculum—with how we’re structuring teaching and learning in Albany County,” Yennie said. “From the survey instrument, we’ve spent a great deal of time over the past year developing a strategic plan that echoes a lot of these concerns we’re seeing here.”

By establishing trust with students, ACSD #1 is also offering a sense of purpose—an element University of Virginia sociologist James Davison Hunter explains is crucial to developing good character.

“Implicit in the word character is a story. It is a story about living for a purpose that is greater than the self,” Hunter wrote in The Tragedy of Moral Education in America. “Though this purpose resides deeply within, its origins are outside the self, and so it beckons one forward, channeling one’s passions to mostly quiet acts of devotion, heroism, sacrifice, and achievement.”

In other words, student voice is important not as mere self-expression, but in connecting to a purpose that’s bigger than the self.

The Jubilee Centre offers a resource on connecting to a purpose in one’s life, asking students to imagine that they are looking back on their lives 70 or 80 years from now and to reflect on whether they have lived well.

Parents, students united on purpose of education

Students weighing in on what they view as the purpose of education are pointing to college readiness, and discovering a passion and practical life skills, in alignment with parents and others who stress the importance of lessons that develop good character.

The Atlantic recently teamed with The Hechinger Report to survey students about what they hope to get out of their education, and it’s clear many pupils are looking for a well-rounded education that focuses as much on finding a passion in life as mastering traditional subjects like math, English and reading.

Baltimore School for the Arts junior Ifetayo Kitwala said she’s looking to broaden her horizons at school by learning from her classmates to develop an appreciation for other cultures that she can carry with her through life.

“I feel like schools could be a place where I can learn about their culture and where they came from and (they) can learn about mine. And, of course, you know, have your science and math, and learn how to write,” Kitwala said. “But also be, not necessarily a culture shock, but a place to broaden your mind.

“If you don’t do it young, then you’ll never do it, in my opinion,” she said.

Jadaci Henderson, a senior at Dumas New Tech High School in Arkansas, told the news site she hopes to gain an education that will help her “be a functioning member of society who can work, who can educate someone else, who can be a role model.”

Others, like USC Hybrid High School—Los Angeles sophomore Lilianna Salcedo, think “the role of teachers and education in general is to help us progress as a society.”

“Not only in our smarts or technology,” she said, “but to help us progress as a human race: preparing us to tackle the issues that (our predecessors) couldn’t defeat.”

Most of the students interviewed, whether they recognize it or not, want lessons that instill good character traits that will prepare them for both the workforce and academia, as well as a life of purpose.

And their parents want the same.

“The overwhelming majority of American parents (96 percent) say ‘strong moral character’ is very important, if not essential, to their children’s future,” according to “Culture of American Families,” a 2012 report by the Institute for Advanced Studies in Culture.

Schools should prompt students to think about what “the good life” means to them.

The Jubilee Centre for Character and Virtues offers a lesson, “Beginning at the End, Towards ‘The Good Life,’” that helps teachers lead students by imagining themselves looking back on their lives 70 or 80 years from now and discussing what they’ve hoped to have accomplished.

“How do your current actions further or undermine the ‘good life’ that you hope to have led, at the end of the next 70 or 80 years or so?” the assignment asks.

The lesson prompts students to think about what truly motivates them—pleasure, wealth, status, power, knowledge, or ethical living—and to consider the perspective of the philosopher Aristotle, who argues that a life marked by courage, self-control, generosity, friendliness, discretion, truthfulness, and other attributes of good character is ultimately the most rewarding.

“In fact, Aristotle thinks that being able to live out these and other ‘virtues’ in the differing contexts of our lives, is actually what makes up . . . a life well lived, and indeed, worth living,” the assignment reads.

Social-emotional learning and achievement at Valor

Valor Collegiate Academies in Tennessee is crediting a sharp focus on social and emotional learning (SEL) for students’ astonishing academic success, which propelled its Tennessee schools to the top 1 percent of all middle schools in the state in its first year.

The success at Valor not only sheds light on the value of social-emotional learning, but also provides an opportunity to connect those lessons with broader discussions about good character and morals.

The Charter School Growth Fund, which invested $1.5 million for Valor’s first two schools launched in 2013, featured the schools in a recent “CSGF Portfolio Spotlight” on the organization’s website.

Todd Dickson, CEO of Valor Collegiate Academies, explained that the concept for the charter school was inspired by his work at a high-performing charter school in California that focused heavily on academics, and his twin brother Daren’s time helping children in social services with social and emotional skills.

“Students at Valor spend more time on their social and emotional growth than most traditional students. We first work on self-awareness and self-management to help them develop a strong sense of who they are. Then, we work on social awareness and social management to help them develop positive relationships with others. We believe that doing both things well helps develop healthy kids and communities,” Dickson said.

“We also hear from students that they feel safe here and that they have trusting relationships with peers and adults in the building. This has been beneficial in an academic setting; scholars are more willing to take academic risks. They listen to other people’s opinions and accept a diversity of perspectives.”

Valor schools use “The Valor Compass” to guide student growth and help them focus on four primary objectives: Sharp Minds, Noble Purpose, Big Hearts, and Aligned Actions.

“Mentor time, Expeditions, and academic courses all incorporate explicit and experiential experiences to help scholars develop sharp minds, big hearts, noble purpose, and aligned actions,” according to the Valor website. “Valor scholars develop character strengths such as kindness, determination, curiosity, gratitude, and integrity within a supportive community.”

Ryan Olson, director of the Institute for Advanced Studies on Culture at the University of Virginia, points out in “Character Education” that an SEL researcher argued that “the orientation of social-emotional learning toward action and skill” in SEL programs can complement the “concern for volition and intention often found in character and moral education programs.”

Adding curriculum resources on why students should do and be good—reasons outside oneself and for the benefit of others and a community—improves the stickiness of character formation, and getting students to go deeper by working on developing good sense when there is conflict between the social and emotional skills they’re learning, is an excellent next step, Olson argues.

The UK’s Jubilee Centre offers a worksheet to assist teachers to help students think about the kind of person and type of life they want to pursue.